Call To Begin A Consultation
Prior Lake952-226-2015
View Our Practice Areas

Bad law makes hard cases


It is sometimes said about the law that hard cases make bad law. This means that difficult decisions often result in tortured rationales. But sometimes, the opposite is true, where a bad law results in a difficult case.

In a case involving a woman from Minnesota who was the surrogate mother and English man, who was the biological father, a British law has resulted in an absurd decision. A British court ruled that he could not be recognized as the father of the child because he is single. 


A court in the U.S. has recognized him as father, and the surrogate mother (he supplied the sperm and a donor egg) and social workers in both countries both approve of the recognition.

A British law from 2008 prohibits a single person from being recognized as a parent in this situation. At the same time, it allows couples, no matter their configuration, married, living together, heterosexual or same-sex, to be recognized as parent.

However, it prevents any single person from obtaining a child via surrogacy, no matter how good a parent they would make. Parliament apparently felt allowing a single individual to obtain a child by surrogacy was very different than permitting them to adopt.

Whatever their reasons, the result in this case is a child who could seemingly become a permanent ward of the court, absent legislative change. Perhaps this case will remove the discussion from abstract generalities and principles to the harsh reality of a baby deprived of his biological father.

It is possible that that this case could spur a change in this law.

Source: Telegraph.com.uk, "Baby boy trapped in legal limbo after family judge rules father has no legal rights over his son," John Bingham, September 8, 2015

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

We Can Help Ask us how - please call our family law offices at 612-200-2822 or fill out the form below to arrange a consultation.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

Offices Conveniently located in Minneapolis and Prior Lake
  • Minneapolis Office
    2100 Fifth Street Towers
    100 South Fifth Street
    Minneapolis, MN 55402

    Toll Free: 800-219-0858
    Phone: 612-200-2822
    Fax: 612-605-0968
    Minneapolis Law Office Map

    Prior Lake Office
    14093 Commerce Avenue
    Prior Lake, MN 55372

    Toll Free: 800-219-0858
    Phone: 952-314-2617
    Phone: 952-226-2015
    Fax: 612-605-0968
    Map & Directions

  • Minneapolis Office Map
    • VISA
  • Prior Office Map